The Property Buying Company Review: How They Compare to Bettermove

The Property Buying Company describes itself as the most-reviewed cash house buyer on Trustpilot and runs a direct-purchase model and an investor network alongside it. We review how they work and compare them honestly with Bettermove.

RoryRoryOperations Manager8 min readSep 2026

The Property Buying Company (TPBC) was founded in 2012 by Karl McArdle and Jonathan Christie, is based in Wetherby, and has grown into one of the larger names in the sector: around 2,700 Trustpilot reviews, NAPB and TPO membership and a model that mirrors Bettermove’s more closely than most, with a direct cash purchase from their own funds and a network of pre-vetted investors for sellers who want a higher figure and can wait. They are a credible, well-run operator. The differences worth understanding are around what happens after the survey, how firmly the first offer holds, and the conditions attached to the “no fees” promise.

The Property Buying Company: key facts and figures

The Property Buying Company Limited was incorporated in April 2012 and is based in Wetherby, West Yorkshire. They describe themselves as a genuine cash buyer that purchases directly with their own funds, and also run an in-house estate agency and an investor-sourcing arm, so a seller who prefers a higher price than the cash offer can be introduced to their investor buyers instead. They are a member of the National Association of Property Buyers (they describe themselves as a founding member; the NAPB register lists their membership from March 2016) and are registered with The Property Ombudsman under the residential property buying companies scheme. Their published offer range is 75% to 85% of full market value, they say most sellers complete in two to three weeks with seven days possible, and their fees promise covers legal and survey costs provided you use the solicitor they provide. Coverage is England and Wales.

How The Property Buying Company works

The process is the familiar one. You give them the property details and receive an initial offer; if you want to proceed they arrange a survey, which they say they typically commission on every property they buy directly, and the formal offer follows. Their marketing says their offers are guaranteed and that what they offer is what you get; their own how-it-works page qualifies that by explaining that the sale is guaranteed as long as everything has been described accurately and that survey findings which severely affect value can change the figure. Read together, that is the industry-standard position: a firm offer after survey, not before. If the cash figure is below what you hoped for, they will offer to introduce you to investors from their network, a route they note takes longer.

What The Property Buying Company do well

  • An established operator trading since 2012, with a large Trustpilot review base (4.4 from around 2,700 reviews)
  • Genuine direct cash buyer using their own funds, with an investor network as a second route, so sellers have a choice within one company
  • NAPB member (a founding member, by their account) and registered with The Property Ombudsman
  • Completion in as little as 7 days, with most sales taking 2 to 3 weeks, they say
  • No fees to the seller, with legal and survey costs covered when you use their solicitor
  • National press profile: their site carries Daily Express and Daily Mirror features

What to watch out for

  • As with most cash buyers, Bettermove included, the “no fees” and “legal costs covered” promises apply when you use the solicitor they provide; ask what happens to those costs if you prefer your own
  • The “offers are guaranteed” headline is qualified on their own site by survey findings; ask them to put in writing exactly what can and cannot change the figure after survey
  • Survey transparency: they do not say publicly whether the full survey report is shared with the seller, so ask
  • Several one-star reviews describe the offer being reduced late in the process, and some mention poor handover between staff; agree a named contact from the start
  • They describe the investor route as an alternative that takes longer, so ask how it is priced and what commitment they need from you

The Property Buying Company vs Bettermove: how they compare

Both companies are genuine direct cash buyers with an investor route alongside, both are NAPB and TPO members, and both have a substantial review history. The differences sit in the small print around fees and the survey stage, and in how the two routes are offered.

Side-by-side comparisonThe Property Buying CompanyBettermove
Founded20122014
NAPB member✓✓
TPO member✓✓
Trustpilot score4.4 ★ (c. 2,700 reviews)4.6 ★ (2,406 reviews)
Fees to sellerNone (with their solicitor)None
Legal costs covered✓ (their panel solicitor)✓ (our recommended solicitors)
Direct cash buyer✓✓
Offer level stated75% to 85% of market valueUp to 80% (cash route)
Survey findings explainedAsk directly✓ Any change explained, with the reason
Price PromiseSurvey-qualified offer guarantee✓ Match or beat a firm written offer
Investor network route✓ (slower alternative)✓ (up to 93% of market value)
CoverageEngland & WalesEngland & Wales

Figures correct as at November 2026. Trustpilot scores and review counts change daily; check both companies’ profiles for the latest figures before you decide.

What the Trustpilot scores tell you

The Property Buying Company’s 4.4 from around 2,700 reviews is a serious dataset, larger than Bettermove’s, and it deserves respect: you cannot sustain a 4.4 across that many transactions without doing most things well. The difference to Bettermove’s score is small, and both figures sit in the same band. What the two profiles are more useful for is the shape of the complaints. Some of TPBC’s one-star reviews describe an offer being reduced late in the process, and some describe being passed between staff while it happened. That does not mean it will happen to you, but it tells you which two questions to ask before you accept an offer: what can change the figure after survey, and who is my single point of contact.

💡 TPBC and Bettermove both offer a cash route and an investor route. If you are comparing them, compare like with like: ask each for a written cash offer and a written investor-route estimate, with the timescale and any commitment attached to each.

“A big review count is a good sign, but read the one-star reviews before the five-star ones. They tell you what a company does when something goes wrong, and that is the bit you are actually buying.”

Rory, Operations Manager, Bettermove

Bettermove’s verdict

The Property Buying Company are one of the most established and most-reviewed operators in the UK cash buying market, and if you are comparing quick-sale companies they should be on your shortlist. Their model is one of the closest to ours in this series, which makes the comparison a fair one: two direct cash buyers with an investor network behind them. Where we believe Bettermove offers more is in explaining any change after the survey in full, with the reason, and in our written Price Promise. Get written offers from both, ask both the same questions about the survey stage and the solicitor conditions, and if their firm written offer is higher, tell us and we will match or beat it, or tell you honestly why we can’t.

Ready to take the next step?

Speak to the Bettermove team for free, personalised advice. No obligation, no pressure.

Get a free cash offer →

Video library

More from Bettermove

Selling your home with Bettermove

How the cash offer process works

What our customers say